1031 Exchange – explained
I put this together to explain the rules and the process of a 1031 exchange in plain words. The example sells a condo in Florida and buys a condo in Massachusetts or New Hampshire. Let me know if you have questions. I am available to talk through your plan.
What a 1031 exchange is
You sell an investment property, buy another one, and put off the capital gains tax. The tax is not erased. It moves into the new property and comes due when you sell for cash.
- Real estate only. Since 2018, only real property qualifies. Equipment, vehicles and art no longer do.
- No cap right now. There is no limit on the gain you can put off. Congress has talked about a cap but has not passed one.
- You can repeat it. Heirs generally get a stepped up basis, which can wipe out the deferred tax. Ask your CPA how that fits your plan.
Does your property qualify?
- Investment or business use. Rentals, commercial buildings and land held for income or growth. Not your home, and not a flip.
- U.S. real estate on both sides. Real estate outside the United States is not like-kind to U.S. real estate.
- Same name on both deeds. The owner who sells must be the owner who buys.
- A qualified intermediary. A neutral third party holds your sale money. You never touch it.
What “like-kind” means
Like-kind is about the nature of the property, not the type or quality. A rental condo in Florida is like-kind to a rental condo in Massachusetts or New Hampshire. It is also like-kind to an apartment building or land.
Qualifies
- Rental house, condo or apartment building
- Office, retail or industrial building
- Vacant land held for investment
- Ground lease of 30 years or more
- Delaware Statutory Trust shares (ask your advisor)
Does not qualify
- Your home or a personal-use second home
- Flips and other property held for resale
- Property outside the United States
- Furniture, equipment and vehicles
- Stocks, bonds and partnership interests
Key terms
- Relinquished property. The investment property you sell. Also called the old property.
- Replacement property. The investment property you buy with the sale money. Also called the new property.
- Qualified Intermediary (QI). A neutral third party who holds your sale money and buys the new property for you.
- Boot. Cash or other value you take out of the exchange, including a smaller new mortgage. Boot is taxable.
- Adjusted basis. What you paid, plus improvements, minus depreciation claimed. Gain is the sale price minus this.
- Depreciation recapture. Tax on depreciation you deducted. Up to 25% in a sale. Deferred in an exchange.
- Constructive receipt. Having access to or control of the sale money, even briefly. It disqualifies the exchange.
- Identification. A signed, written list of replacement properties given to your QI by midnight of day 45.
- Delayed exchange. The standard type. Sell first, then buy within the 45 and 180 day windows.
- Reverse exchange. Buy the new property first, then sell the old one. Same clocks, usually higher cost.
- Deferred gain. The gain you postpone. It carries into the new property and is taxed on a later cash sale.
- Form 8824. The IRS form that reports the exchange. Filed with the tax return for the year you sold.
The rules: what you must do
- Same taxpayer. Title on the old and new property stays in the same name.
- Investment use. Both properties are U.S. real estate held for investment or business.
- Use a QI. Hire one before closing. Sale money goes to the QI, never to you.
- Day 45. Identify replacement properties in writing, signed, delivered to the QI.
- Day 180. Close on the new property within 180 days or by your tax return due date, whichever is first.
- Equal or greater. Buy at or above your net sale price and reinvest all net proceeds.
- Replace the debt. A new mortgage at least equals the old one, or add cash to make up the gap.
- Report it. File Form 8824 with the tax return for the year you sold.
The timeline: 45 and 180 days
| Day | What happens | Example date |
|---|---|---|
| Day 0 | Sale closes. Proceeds go to the QI. Both clocks start. | Fri, Jan 15, 2027 |
| Day 45 | Signed list of replacement properties due to the QI by midnight. | Mon, Mar 1, 2027 |
| Day 180 | The replacement property must close by this date. | Wed, Jul 14, 2027 |
The 180 days include the 45. You do not get 225. Miss either date and the full gain is taxable. Sold late in the year? Your deadline can be your tax return due date, including extensions, if that comes first.
How many properties you can identify
- Three-Property Rule. Name up to three properties, at any value. Buy one, two or all three.
- 200% Rule. Name any number, if their combined value is no more than 200% of what you sold for.
- 95% Rule. Name more than that, but then you must buy at least 95% of the total value you named.
Identify in writing, signed, with a street address or legal description, delivered to your QI by midnight of day 45. The list is locked after that.
The process, step by step
- Plan before you list. Talk to your CPA and to me. Confirm investment use and estimate the gain.
- Hire a QI before closing. Sign the exchange agreement.
- Add exchange language to the sale contract. The buyer agrees to cooperate.
- Close the sale. Proceeds go straight to the QI. This is day 0.
- Identify replacements by day 45. In writing, signed, delivered to the QI.
- Inspect, finance and negotiate. Line up the loan early.
- Close by day 180. The QI wires the funds. Title goes in the same name.
- File Form 8824 with the tax return for the year you sold.
Professionals to hire
- Qualified Intermediary. Holds the sale money and handles the exchange paperwork. Must be independent of you. The IRS does not license QIs, so check them out.
- CPA or tax advisor. Estimates gain, boot and recapture, sets your new basis, and files Form 8824 and your state return.
- Real estate attorney. Reviews the contracts, the exchange language and the condo documents.
- Me and my team. I help find replacement properties and keep the 45 and 180 day dates on track.
- Lender. Lines up financing early so the new loan covers the old debt.
- Title company. Clears title and confirms the new deed is in the same name as the sale deed.
Example: a Florida condo to a Massachusetts condo
All figures are illustrative. The owner lives in Massachusetts. There is no mortgage on the sale or the purchase, so this is a cash to cash exchange. It assumes the top 20% federal long-term rate, the 3.8% net investment income tax, about $200,000 of depreciation, and total income under the Massachusetts surtax threshold. Your CPA will use your actual numbers.
Part 1: selling the Florida condo
| Florida rental condo | Amount |
|---|---|
| Sale price | $1,000,000 |
| Selling costs | −$60,000 |
| Net sale price | $940,000 |
| Original cost (2014) | $600,000 |
| Depreciation claimed | −$200,000 |
| Adjusted basis | $400,000 |
| Gain | $540,000 |
| Mortgage | $0 |
| Cash held by the QI | $940,000 |
Tax if you simply sold: recapture $200,000 × 25% = $50,000. Remaining gain $340,000 × 20% = $68,000. Investment income tax 3.8% = $20,520. Massachusetts $540,000 × 5% = $27,000. Total: $165,520. Florida charges none, but Massachusetts taxes you as a resident.
Part 2: buying a condo in Massachusetts
Replacement: one condo, bought for $950,000 in cash and rented out. It is funded with $940,000 from the QI plus $10,000 of your own cash. No mortgage.
- $950,000 is above the $940,000 net sale price.
- All $940,000 held by the QI is reinvested.
- No debt before or after, so no debt boot.
Result: $0 tax due now. $165,520 put off ($138,520 federal plus $27,000 Massachusetts). New basis of $410,000, which is $950,000 minus the $540,000 deferred gain. A New Hampshire condo works the same way. The condo must be held as a rental.
Part 3: what if the condo costs less?
Say the new condo costs $800,000, all cash. The price is $140,000 below the $940,000 net sale price, so the QI hands that $140,000 back to you. That cash is boot. It costs about $47,320 this year: $40,320 federal plus $7,000 Massachusetts. The rest of the gain stays deferred.
The fix: buy at or above the net sale price, or buy two or three condos. You can name up to three properties.
If you live in Massachusetts
Massachusetts taxes a resident on gains and rent from anywhere. New Hampshire having no income tax does not change that for you.
- Massachusetts. Long-term gains 5%, short-term 8.5% (2026). 4% surtax on income over $1,107,750 (2026). Deed excise tax of $4.56 per $1,000 of price.
- New Hampshire. No state tax on capital gains or personal income. Transfer tax of $0.75 per $100, paid by buyer and by seller. Business Profits Tax can apply to an active real estate business.
- Florida. No state income tax. Your CPA can confirm how Massachusetts treats the exchange.
How exchanges fail
- Touching the money. If sale money reaches your account, even for a day, the exchange is dead.
- Missing a date. Day 45 and day 180 have no grace period.
- Hiring the QI late. The QI must be in place before the sale closes.
- Buying down. A lower price or smaller mortgage creates taxable boot.
- Title mismatch. The buyer on the new deed must be the seller on the old one.
- Related party or move-in. Deals with relatives need a 2 year hold. If you plan to live in the condo, talk to me before you buy.
Five things to remember
- Plan first. Pick a QI and a CPA before you list.
- Never touch the sale money.
- 45 days to identify, 180 days to close, running together.
- Buy equal or greater value and replace the debt.
- Report it on Form 8824. Deferred is not forgiven.
Let me know if you have questions. I am available to talk through your plan. Ned Mahoney, My Town Real Estate Team, 617-799-0566, ned@nedmahoney.com.
General information as of November 2026. Not tax or legal advice. Confirm your facts with a CPA and an attorney.











Twitter
Youtube
LinkedIn
RSS
Facebook